A Letter to /r/python
(with some notes about bipolar disorder)
There were a few recent threads that occurred in /r/python which greatly disturbed me, because of their general tone towards both me, and a tool that I’ve been toiling on very hard over the past year and a half.
- Why is pipenv the recommended packaging tool by the community and PyPA? (very negative)
- Pipenv review, after using it in production (mostly great!)
- Kenneth Reitz - Pipenv: The Future of Python Dependency Management - PyCon 2018 (mostly positive, some negativity)
I mention negativity, because it sprung forth from some of these threads in a very aggressive manner, from some very (in these threads) vocal members of the /r/python community.
It appears I have some haters out there. This is new to me.
One comment, for example, struck me as extremely odd:
If only these people didn't advertise themselves as the next best thing to sliced bread, collecting undeserved fame, jobs, influence, and as consequence harming very large number of people and technology in general, I wouldn't mind them doing whatever projects they like.
My response to this comment is — first off, my fame, while certainly categorized under “cult of personality” is not necessarily accidental. It’s called marketing. I worked very hard at becoming well known within the Python community, and toiled away at it for years. The popularity of Requests was accidental, but there were many libraries that existed before it that I had created in an attempt to get GitHub stars. I wanted to be like Armin Ronacher on GitHub. I succeeded.
Also, for the past 6.5 years, I have not had the most glorious job in the world. I consider myself to have been mildly underpaid, considering what I was responsible for — the entire deployment experience (including uptime) of Python apps on Heroku, one of the largest deployment platforms in the world.
Also, “harming a very large number of people”? What? I’ve never harmed a soul with my influence — I use it to build the community up. I’m not a member of the Social Justice Warrior League (nothing against you if you are — you do you!). I’m Kenneth — a nice guy who builds nice tools and takes a lot of pictures.
So, this comment is just off the rails, and deeply disturbs me.
Another quote from one thread:
Pipenv is garbage.
There are a few things I’d like to say:
- Thank you, /r/python very much for any and all constructive feedback that was provided on Pipenv and how it does/doesn’t fit into your workflow. Every single comment was read and considered carefully, multiple times — though not responded to. Bandwidth is not available for responses, unfortunately.
- If I came across as crass in any comments, please keep in mind that I was very stressed out with all this negative attention (which is rare for me, the attention is typically quite positive). In addition, I had just started a brand new job, and had a week of little sleep at PyCon. Little Sleep + Bipolar Type I == coming across as dismissive, potentially.
- I’m not perfect. I try my hardest to be the kindest, most approachable and open person in Python — but that comes at a great cost to me — and sometimes I just can’t be that. So, if you had an interaction with me, and it tainted your view of me or my projects, I beg you to reconsider your new view — moods come in waves, and I cannot perform at 100% at all moments. It’s simply not possible.
- I have limited mental bandwidth, and parsing through and individually responding to hundreds of comments filled with personal opinions, often with slightly misaligned views of Python packaging is not within my capacity. I have a lot on my plate, between having a brand new job, managing my freely available web services, keeping up with technology, managing my open source projects, making music, taking photos, learning Kubernetes/Docker, random emails from random people asking random questions, mentorship requests, keynote requests, and orchestrating a new revision of The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Python from O’Reilly. The amount of inbound requests I have incoming is tremendous, and I simply don’t have the bandwidth to respond to all the valid comments and concerns in /r/python, so I’m addressing them here, in macro mode.
To those that criticize the project for making too many releases (multiple releases a day) — I’ll say a few things:
- That was a manic period of mine (again, bipolar). I was working on Pipenv for 20+ hours a day for over 4 weeks. Yes, many releases were required. One for each bugfix.
- I’d rather go manic over a codebase than over magic/crystals/the cosmos. This was a very healthy expression for me — I’m sorry if it concerned anyone, but these are the constraints my brain places upon me. I have a severe mental disability, and I’m coping with it very well.
- There was only a period of one month when this occurred, it is not our normal release cadence.
- We just switched the project over to calver, with the explicit purpose of preventing me from making more than one release a day — so this shouldn’t be an issue going forward.
- To prevent such things from happening with Requests, I actually revoked my own credentials from PyPI to Requests last year. This has been successful.
- Pipenv is a tool that is widely adopted, and quickly becoming a new workflow standard for many new and experienced Python developers.
- It is, above all else, a workflow tool.
- There is a misnomer that Pipenv is not useful for libraries. That is false. Try using
$ pipenv install -e .and see what it does when you lock. It augments
setup.py. I, as a library developer, find that extremely useful.
- Pipenv’s popularity is not because it was written by myself — though that certainly doesn’t hurt. It is because it enforces great practices that most experienced Python developers already employ, but it does them without you having to type any additional commands. Pipenv is primarily a workflow tool, first and foremost. That’s why it’s called “Python Dev Workflow for Humans”.
Pipfile.lock, the replacement for the true thing that is at play here (
requirements.txt), will be landing in pip proper in the future, and when that’s the case, you can use it without using Pipenv! In fact, there’s a huge opportunity here! Someone — go build a Pipfile -> pip tool, today! That’ll solve a huge use case for a large number of people that don’t want to use Pipenv.
- If you don't like the workflow that Pipenv offers, simply stick with what you love! For example: use pip / virtualenv! Don’t overwhelm me on Reddit with your opinions of how it should be different and your justifications for why. We’re a year and half into this project, with a team of 5 highly time–constrained individuals doing our best to keep up with the expectations of an ever-growing audience (170,000 installs this month). It's too late to make changes to the primary design — especially since I view it to be "correct".
- Packing tools are hard. They require a deep understanding of Python infrastructure to build, are extremely difficult to test, and even harder to maintain. People have extremely variant setups. Run
$ python -m pipenv.helpsometime to get an idea for the type of information we're dealing with on a given system. It's insane.
Of all the work I’ve created, I’m most proud of Pipenv — more than I am of Requests. Pipenv was much more difficult to create, and even harder to maintain. Much. And, it has the potential to shape the future of Python in a way that Requests does not.
So — thank you for your time, and thank you for listening to my thoughts and perspective.
I love you all — even if some of you don't love me anymore.
P.S. I'm hosting a Google Hangouts session today, if anyone would like to speak to me about any of these topics.
Thoughts & Musings: a (Public) Journal
A collection of hand-written essays by Kenneth Reitz.
- A Letter to /r/python.
- My Last Manic Episode.
- The Secret to My Success: Stimulants.
- On Polyamory.
- My Favorite Python Libraries.
- Dinner with a Narcissist.
- Competition and Open Source.
- A Good Hat.
- I Do Lots of Things.
- Working from Home — a Double-Edged Sword.
- Truest Love.
- Feeling Better & Reflecting on Open Source.
- iPad as a Main Computer.
- Writing Reasonable Documentation.
- On Depression, Part I (of many).
- On Psychedelics and Other Drugs.
- On Traveling and Depression.
- Pipe Dream: Making a Game.
- On Depression, Part II.
- On Irritability in Open Source.
- A Concise List of Personal Values.
- Why This isn't a Blog.
- Attempting to Reduce Stimulants Usage.
- On Conferences and Travel.
- The Far Side of Madness.
- Esoteric Interest and Current Bookshelf.
- New Project Idea: Environment Variables.
- Back to Work.
- Stuck in a Rut.
- Self Therapy or Professional & Amphetamines.
- Living With Reasonable Regrets.
- Switching Cameras (again).
- It's About Time....
- Soul Purpose.
- Three Concise Truths.
- The Anxiety of Clout.
- Sharing is Therapeutic.
- Positivity, Coming Soon™.
- Fellowship at PyCon (upcomming).
- On Inspiration and Tools (like languages).
- On Writing.
- First Entry.
- On Open Source and Impactfulness.
- Seeking Inspiration, Somewhere.
- On Writing Music and Emotional Landscape.
- Poetic Expressions.